All Division: American
| Big North Conference | ||||||||
| American | ||||||||
| Wrestling | ||||||||
| 2019 | ||||||||
| 1st Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Ryan Kozdra | Mahwah | Freshman | 106 | |||||
| Alex Almeyda | Fort Lee | Freshman | 113 | |||||
| Ethan Fernandez | Westwood | Sophomore | 113 | |||||
| Joseph Manginelli | Dumont | Senior | 120 | |||||
| Gianni Manginelli | Dumont | Senior | 126 | |||||
| Jonathan Siemsen | Ramsey | Sophomore | 126 | |||||
| Trent Furman | Westwood | Senior | 132 | |||||
| Ty Pfeufer | Westwood | Senior | 138 | |||||
| Tyler Deppert | Pascack Hills | Senior | 145 | |||||
| Julian Robles | Westwood | Senior | 152 | |||||
| Stephen Lowery | Ramsey | Senior | 160 | |||||
| Jesse Pressburger | Mahwah | Senior | 170 | |||||
| Kevin McGee | Pascack Hills | Senior | 182 | |||||
| Tyler Myack | Westwood | Senior | 195 | |||||
| Benny Dahdah | Westwood | Senior | 220 | |||||
| Alex Kostantas | Pascack Hills | Sophomore | 220 | |||||
| Dom DiMassimo | Pascack Hills | Senior | 285 | |||||
| 2nd Team All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Ben Bautista | Pascack Hills | Sophomore | 106 | |||||
| Max Martinez | Pascack Hills | Sophomore | 113 | |||||
| Cole Pfeufer | Westwood | Senior | 120 | |||||
| Nicky Eboli | Westwood | Sophomore | 126 | |||||
| Austin Yalowitz | Fort Lee | Freshman | 126 | |||||
| James Sgarella | Dumont | Sophomore | 132 | |||||
| Sean Hernandez | Fort Lee | Senior | 138 | |||||
| Nickolas Chalarca | Dumont | Senior | 145 | |||||
| Tommy Eboli | Westwood | Junior | 145 | |||||
| Sam Spira | Mahwah | Senior | 152 | |||||
| Matt Devito | Dumont | Senior | 160 | |||||
| Nick DiMassimo | Pascack Hills | Junior | 170 | |||||
| Sean Kelly | Ramsey | Sophomore | 182 | |||||
| Jacob Leiva | Cliffside Park | Sophomore | 195 | |||||
| Joe Kozdra | Mahwah | Junior | 195 | |||||
| Jonas Hyman | Ramsey | Junior | 220 | |||||
| Keon Fraser Morrison | Westwood | Junior | 285 | |||||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | ||||||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} | |||||
| Matt Lewis | Mahwah | Senior | 138 | |||||
| Christian Agreda | Mahwah | Mahwah | ||||||
| Matt Biondi | Ramsey | Senior | 120 | |||||
| James Barbato | Ramsey | Senior | 132 | |||||
| Matias Murillo | Pascack Hills | Sophomore | 138 | |||||
| Jineer Contreras | Cliffside Park | Senior | 145 | |||||
| Coach of the year | Sean Firat | |||||||
| School | Cliffside Park | |||||||
