| Big North Conference |
| |
| American |
| Girls Swimming & Diving |
| 2019 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Molly Arts, Gabby Mackle, Ava Gallagher, Kaya Kynz | Ramapo | | 200 Med Relay |
| Ciofalo, Angelica | Mahway | Sophomore | 200 Free |
| Ng, Trystan | Demarest | Sophomore | 200 IM |
| Yoo, Kaitlyn | Demarest | Senior | 50 Free |
| Narayanan, Nisha | Mahwah | Freshman | 100 Fly |
| Soll, Charlotte | Ramsey | Sophomore | 100 Free |
| Woods-Bannan, Rachel | Demarest | Senior | 500 Free |
| Rachel Woods-Bannan, Kaitlyn Yoo, Michelle Lee, Sofia Kontolios, | Demarest | – | 200 Free Relay |
| Arts, Molly | Ramapo | Junior | 100 Back |
| Lee, Michelle | Demarest | Freshman | 100 Breast |
| Claudia Kim, Sofia Kontolios, Trystan Ng, Rachael Woods-Bannan | Demarest | – | 400 Free Relay |
| DeSalvo, Ella | Tenafly | Freshman | open |
| Gallucci, Gabby | Ramapo | Freshman | open |
| Lyou, Sarah | Ramsey | Junior | open |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Trystan Ng, Michelle Lee, Kaitlyn Yoo, Claudia Kim | Demarest | – | 200 Med Relay |
| Seelin, Julia | Ramsey | Senior | 200 Free |
| Gallagher, Ava | Ramapo | Sophomore | 200 IM |
| Lambert, Kenzie | Ramsey | Freshman | 50 Free |
| Nyhuis, Angela | Lakeland | Senior | 100 Fly |
| Knyz, Kaya | Ramapo | Sophomore | 100 Free |
| McIntyre, Emma | Ramsey | Sophomore | 500 Free |
| Kaya Kynz, Carson Levy, Ani Kelly, Molly Arts | Ramapo | – | 200 Free Relay |
| Levy, Carson | Ramapo | Freshman | 100 Back |
| Kim, Noelle | Mahwah | Sophomore | 100 Breast |
| Alice Nam, Kenzie Lambert, Julia Seelin, Charlotte Soll | Ramsey | – | 400 Free Relay |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Olivia O’Donnell | Demarest | Senior | |
| Slaman, Abby | Lakeland | Freshman | |
| Cao, Jennifer | Mahwah | Junior | |
| Fortunato, Natalie | Ramapo | Sophomore | |
| Wong, Erin | Ramsey | | |
| Wadsworth, Anna | Tenafly | Senior | |
| |
| Coach of the year | |
| School | |
