| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Football |
| 2015 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Brad Kropke | Indian Hills | Junior | Lineman |
| Ethan Feingold | Tenafly | Senior | Lineman |
| John Piccinich | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Lineman |
| Stephen Piccinich | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Lineman |
| Stephen Croevani | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior | Lineman |
| Erik Slater | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior | Linebacker |
| James Kelley | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Junior | Linebacker |
| Matt Wisnousky | Indian Hills | Senior | Linebacker |
| Kyle Novotny | Lakeland | Senior | Linebacker |
| Jordan Fuller | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Joe Alzharif | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Ryan Janiga | Indian Hills | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Austin Brackenbury | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Ted Einsidler | Tenafly | Senior | Punter |
| |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Radas Ljusic | Lakeland | Senior | Lineman |
| Florian Kortocia | Indian Hills | Junior | Lineman |
| Allen Ward | Tenafly | Senior | Lineman |
| Dillon Policastro | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Sophomore | Linebacker |
| Anthony Tucci | Indian Hills | Junior | Linebacker |
| Jake Negrin | Lakeland | Senior | Linebacker |
| Max Miller | Tenafly | Senior | Linebacker |
| Gerard McNerney | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Jake Imbosciani | Lakeland | Senior | Defensive Back |
| Thomas Rafferty | Tenafly | Junior | Defensive Back |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Kevin McCloskey | Northern Valley Demarest | Sophomore | Running Back |
| Ryan Vadis | Northern Valley Demarest | Sophomore | Wide Receiver |
| Jarrett Kuipers | Indian Hills | Junior | Wide Receiver |
| Joe Gaudino | Indian Hills | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Justin Nicholson | Lakeland | Senior | Offensive Lineman |
| Mike Rossi | Lakeland | Junior | Linebacker |
| Chris Pella | Northern Valley Old Tappan | Senior | Wide Receiver |
| Pollack | Tenafly | Sophomore | Defensive Line |
| |
| Coach of the year | Joe Sabella |
| School | Indian Hills |
