National: All-Division (Defense)
1st Team
POSITION | NAME | YEAR | SCHOOL |
| LINEMAN | Aristotelis Zigouras | 12 | Tenafly |
| LINEMAN | Andrew Trumbetti | 11 | Demarest |
| LINEMAN | Tony Colabro | 11 | Lakeland |
| LINEMAN | Ethan Frederiks | 12 | Old Tappan |
| LINEMAN | Alex Devito | 12 | Lakeland |
| LINEBACKER | Nick Unger | 12 | Lakeland |
| LINEBACKER | John Albano | 12 | Lakeland |
| LINEBACKER | Rocco Giovinazzo | 11 | Old Tappan |
| LINEBACKER | Ryan Kennelly | 12 | Indian Hills |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Zach Burgess | 12 | Lakeland |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Zach Alsharif | 11 | Old Tappan |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Dylan Fleischer | 12 | Old Tappan |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Matt Liparini | 11 | Demarest |
2nd Team
POSITION | NAME | YEAR | SCHOOL |
| LINEMAN | Vin Delucca | 12 | Lakeland |
| LINEMAN | Michael Masconi | 12 | Indian Hills |
| LINEMAN | Travis Procida | 12 | Old Tappan |
| LINEMAN | Eli Mcgee | 12 | Tenafly |
| LINEBACKER | Anthony Milone | 12 | Demarest |
| LINEBACKER | Tommy Schneider | 12 | Old Tappan |
| LINEBACKER | Andrew Marino | 12 | Tenafly |
| LINEBACKER | Steve Azcurra | 12 | Lakeland |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Sean Mullin | 10 | Lakeland |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Sean Reischel | 12 | Indian Hills |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Anthony Doran | 11 | Demarest |
