Independence: All-Division (Defense)
1st Team
POSITION | NAME | YEAR | SCHOOL |
| LINEMAN | Mike Manente | 12 | Pascack Valley |
| LINEMAN | Bobby Culhane | 12 | Pascack Valley |
| LINEMAN | Christian Albanese | 12 | Ramapo |
| LINEMAN | Lou Caltagirone | 12 | Passaic Valley |
| LINEMAN | Matt Koch | 12 | Passaic Valley |
| LINEBACKER | Logan Schulte | 12 | Ramapo |
| LINEBACKER | David Cruz | 11 | Passaic Valley |
| LINEBACKER | Jimmy Mack | 12 | Bergenfield |
| LINEBACKER | Nick Choman | 12 | Pascack Valley |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Aniello O’Connor | 12 | Ramapo |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Conor Krup | 12 | Ramapo |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Kevin Illian | 12 | Pascack Valley |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Kyle Stackpole | 12 | Bergenfield |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Giovanni Ogilvie | 12 | Bergenfield |
| PUNTER | Andrew Vigorita | 12 | West Milford |
2nd Team
POSITION | NAME | YEAR | SCHOOL |
| LINEMAN | James Hoffman | 11 | West Milford |
| LINEMAN | Maalyjah Goodall-Reid | 12 | Bergenfield |
| LINEMAN | Mark Rigney | 11 | Pascack Valley |
| LINEMAN | Trent Mayfield | 12 | Pascack Valley |
| LINEMAN | Stephen Rossi | 12 | Ramapo |
| LINEBACKER | Jake Morra | 11 | Pascack Valley |
| LINEBACKER | Mike Neal | 12 | Bergenfield |
| LINEBACKER | Chris Boes | 11 | West Milford |
| LINEBACKER | Nick Armagno | 12 | Passaic Valley |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Noah Provenzano | 10 | West Milford |
| DEFENSIVE BACK | Ralph Hroncich | 12 | Ramapo |
