National: All-Division
| Big North Conference | |||||
| National | |||||
| Boys Soccer | |||||
| 2012 | |||||
| 1st Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | |||
| Ray Murphy | Tenafly | Senior | |||
| Nathan Bodenstein | Old Tappan | Senior | |||
| Jay Cho | Old Tappan | Junior | |||
| Justin Marko | Demerest | Senior | |||
| Mattew Diehl | Demerest | Senior | |||
| Derek Perrucci | Demerest | Senior | |||
| Blake Ruzich | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Kieran Walsh | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Matt Giovatto | Pascack Valley | Junior | |||
| Justin Sunseri | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Walter Nolasco | Bergenfield | Junior | |||
| Kevin Ramirez | Bergenfield | Senior | |||
| Peter Rogers | Bergenfield | Junior | |||
| Gustavo Grisales | Beregnfield | Senior | |||
| Sergio Mejia | Bergenfield | Junior | |||
| Leutrim Saiti | Teaneck | Junior | |||
| 2nd Team All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | |||
| Niv Nahar | Tenafly | Senior | |||
| Adam Warner | Tenafly | Senior | |||
| John O’Reilly | Old Tappan | Junior | |||
| Paul Tierney | Old Tappan | Junior | |||
| Nicholas Johnson | Old Tappan | Junior | |||
| Cory Gottleib | Pascak Valley | Junior | |||
| Dante Cassano | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Chris Jackson | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Nick Delia | Pascak Valley | Senior | |||
| Eric Tiefer | Demerest | Junior | |||
| Wilmer Jovel-Reyes | Demerest | Junior | |||
| Jeffrey Rodriguez | Demerest | Sophomore | |||
| Bryan Blandon | Bergenfield | Sophomore | |||
| Andreas Papapetrou | Bergenfield | Senior | |||
| Juan Arango | Bergenfield | Senior | |||
| Juan Giraldo | Bergenfield | Bergenfield | |||
| Honorable Mention All-Division | |||||
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | |||
| Juan Lopez | Bergenfield | Senior | |||
| Zachery Lo | Demerest | Senior | |||
| Ben Evans | Pascack Valley | Senior | |||
| Thomas Ferrante | Old Tappan | Junior | |||
| Ben Greenberg | Tenafly | Senior | |||
| Coach of the year | Michael Papapetrou | ||||
| School | Bergenfield | ||||
