| Big North Conference |
| |
| National |
| Baseball |
| 2013 |
| 1st Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| John O’Reilly | Old Tappan | Junior | Pitcher |
| Brandon Issa | Old Tappan | Junior | Pitcher |
| Troy Elias | Demarest | Senior | Pitcher |
| Jordan Matthews | Teaneck | Junior | Pitcher |
| Bill Malley | Bergenfield | Senior | First Base |
| Nick Ruscigno | Teaneck | Senior | Infield |
| Jonathan Avallone | Demarest | Senior | Infield |
| Steve Sabo | Tenafly | Senior | Infield |
| Dimitri Rueger | Teaneck | Senior | Outfield |
| Justin Marko | Demarest | Senior | Outfield |
| John Trainor | Old Tappan | Senior | Outfield |
| Rick Tiburcio | Pascack Valley | Junior | Outfield |
| Sean Haveron | Old Tappan | Senior | DH |
| Lucas Mazurek | Old Tappan | Senior | Utility |
| Harrison Preschell | Teaneck | Senior | Catcher |
| | | | |
| 2nd Team All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | Year | Position {optional} |
| Ryan Vasel | Pascack Valley | Sophomore | Pitcher |
| Scott Oberhelman | Old Tappan | Junior | Pitcher |
| Christian Runza | Old Tappan | Junior | Catcher |
| Joe Lappi | Bergenfield | Junior | Catcher |
| Leo Voreacos | Teaneck | Junior | First Base |
| Kwestin Smith | Teaneck | Senior | Infield |
| Mason Vialonga | Old Tappan | Senior | Infield |
| Pete DeLuca | Demarest | Senior | Infield |
| Mike Scalia | Pascack Valley | Senior | Infield |
| Josh Duster | Teaneck | Senior | Outfield |
| George Gillies | Demarest | Junior | Outfield |
| Tishaun Conde | Teaneck | Senior | DH |
| Jacob McGowan | Tenafly | Junior | Utility |
| |
| Honorable Mention All-Division |
| Student-Athlete’s Name | Name of member school | | |
| Ivan Rodriguez & Josh Lewis | Teaneck | | |
| Chris Hamersma & Louis Bertolotti | Tenafly | | |
| John Volmer & Danny Leonardo | Bergenfield | | |
| Ryan MacNaughton & Ryan Orr | Pascack Valley | | |
| Brian Kelly & Dom Fazio | Demarest | | |
| Doug Ewen & Dan Jablonski | Old Tappan | | |
| |
| Coach of the year | Tim Byron |
| School | Old Tappan |
